Home / Insights / Industry news

Fire retardant corrosion: what NTSB found

On 17 November 2026 the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) called on the US Forest Service (USFS) to strengthen corrosion testing for aerial firefighting retardants. The investigation, published as Aviation Investigation Report AIR-26-06 (report date 2 November 2026), found corrosion damage on two large airtankers that took part in a 2023 operational evaluation.

What the source reports

The aircraft were a British Aerospace BAE-146 operated by Neptune Aviation Services and a McDonnell-Douglas MD-87 operated by Aero Air. Both took part in a USFS evaluation of a new magnesium chloride-based fire retardant during the 2023 season. The evaluation began with exclusive use of the new retardant and then moved to alternating it with a phosphate-based retardant.

Operators documented corrosion and material deposits. Later inspections found extensive corrosion in primary wing structure, fuselage components, electrical connectors, control cables and engines. Comparable aircraft that had not carried the new retardant did not show corresponding corrosion. The report states that chemical corrosion can "weaken aircraft structures and, if left undetected or uncorrected, lead to structural failure".

At the NTSB's request, the US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) examined components removed from two airtankers, together with samples of two retardants, and found that some components had experienced galvanic corrosion.

What the qualification testing relied on

The NTSB found the USFS qualification process relied mainly on corrosion testing of isolated metal samples. It did not adequately account for the combinations of materials and structures found in aircraft, or for the effects of mixing chemically different retardants.

The report records warnings before the evaluation went ahead. A USFS report on its 2021 evaluation of an earlier magnesium chloride-based retardant had recommended testing aircraft materials, including stainless steels, aluminium alloys, magnesium, nickel and titanium, to an aeronautical standard such as ASTM F482-09, Standard Practice for Corrosion of Aircraft Metals by Total Immersion in Maintenance Chemicals. In August 2022 large-airtanker operators told the USFS that existing testing did not account for the various alloys in airtankers or the effects of exposing them to different retardants, and raised concern about magnesium chloride-based products and deposits where retardants interacted. By July 2023, separate testing had documented substantial residue build-up and operational problems with some combinations of phosphate and magnesium chloride retardants. The NTSB found no evidence that these recommendations or results were built into the evaluation before its second phase.

The USFS suspended the qualification of the new retardant and a related product in May 2024 and removed both from its Qualified Products List in December 2024. The NTSB concluded that these actions did not address the underlying deficiencies in the qualification process. It also noted that the USFS had commissioned modified salt-fog testing of several aluminium alloys under alternating spray-and-dry conditions; preliminary results showed uniform-corrosion rates within the specification limits, but no final report was available.

The two recommendations ask the USFS to develop, with industry experts, operators and manufacturers, more complete corrosion testing procedures covering materials typically used in aircraft construction, built-up structures, galvanic coupling, retardant comingling and possible chemical interaction effects (A-26-66), and to write them into Specification 5100-304d, Long-Term Retardant, Wildland Firefighting (A-26-67).

What it means for plant and pipework

The rest of this section is our reading, not the NTSB's. Process plants make the same kind of decision whenever they approve a cleaning agent, corrosion inhibitor, biocide or fire-water additive. A single-metal immersion test answers one question: how fast does this alloy corrode in this liquid. It does not answer what happens where two metals touch, where a crevice holds the liquid, where deposits form, or where wet and dry cycles repeat.

The NTSB report shows how that gap can persist. The warnings existed before the evaluation, and the corrosion was documented once the chemical was used on real aircraft.

Questions to ask before you rely on a chemical treatment

Related reading

Source: US National Transportation Safety Board, press release of 17 November 2026 and Aviation Investigation Report AIR-26-06.