Home / Insights / Industry news and historical failures

HF02: a crude overhead elbow lost 59% of its wall, and the steel was not the problem

Crude overhead failures: the cause was in the operating records

The MTIS Review of Historical Failures takes a published failure investigation, summarises what the original investigators found, and then shows what the MTIS Failure Investigation Assistant made of the same evidence, including where it went wrong. HF02 comes from a Saudi Aramco paper published in Hydrocarbon Processing in August 2026.

What happened

Two carbon steel elbows from the overhead system of an atmospheric crude distillation column were examined after seven years in service. The overhead ran at about 139 °C and 15.5 psi, carrying light hydrocarbons, with wash water and chemical injection upstream of the condensers.

What the investigators found

For the 36-in. elbow, the corrosion product read about pH 3 and contained up to 7.2 wt% chloride with no nitrogen. Ammonium chloride salt is the other usual cause of corrosion in a crude overhead. It contains nitrogen, so a deposit with chloride but no nitrogen points to hydrochloric acid, not ammonium chloride. The steel had a normal ferrite-pearlite microstructure, so the material behaved as carbon steel should in acid condensate.

The authors put the thinning down to hydrochloric acid attack caused by poor chloride control. The process records showed why:

The 48-in. elbow failed differently. The neutraliser amine stream was hitting the wall and causing erosion-corrosion. Its injection quill sat in the elbow itself, was inserted to 11% of the pipe diameter against a recommended 30 to 35%, discharged through a slit, and had no atomising steam.

What it means for asset owners

When an overhead line thins, a common first response is to upgrade the alloy. In this case the steel was normal, and both elbows traced back to operating settings and injection design. A metallurgical examination that stops at the sample will confirm the damage mechanism and miss the cause. Process records, injection details and chemical treatment history belong in the evidence from the start.

What an engineer should check

How the MTIS Failure Investigation Assistant handled this case

Test on a published case, not an accuracy claim.

This test was run on V0, an earlier version of the MTIS Failure Investigation Assistant's failure mode diagnosis engine. The current version is limited to helping an engineer identify the failure mode of a metallurgical failure.

MTIS built a test case for the 36-in. elbow only, from our own summary of the paper. The incident report was written as a plant engineer would write it and left out chloride, pH, acid and dew point. We then gave the app the evidence in three steps. One run, engine version 87ba1de277, 6 October 2026.

Evidence given to the appApp's leading answerScoreRank of hydrochloric acid corrosion
Incident report onlyHydrochloric acid corrosion11.1 / 100 (low)1st (runner-up 5.4)
+ laboratory report and operating-data reviewUniform corrosion45.5 / 100 (moderate)2nd (40.1)
+ answers to the app's own questions (14 asked, 3 answerable from the case)Hydrochloric acid corrosion88.2 / 100 (high)1st (runner-up 54.9)

What it missed or could not do

  • With only the incident report, the app's top suggestion scored just 11 out of 100. That is weak, because the report already says the failure was in a crude column overhead.
  • Adding the laboratory report made the ranking worse. The general "uniform corrosion" mode overtook hydrochloric acid corrosion by about 5 points. The app's follow-up questions put it back in front.
  • 11 of the 14 questions could not be answered from the published case (flow velocity, welds and microbial activity among them) and were left as unknown.

Source. T. A. Al-Ghamdi, Y. A. Aldossary, K. F. Al-Qahtani and E. S. Al-Zahrani (Saudi Aramco), "Metallurgical investigation of crude distillation overhead system: A case study", Hydrocarbon Processing, August 2026. Read the original article. Figures quoted are the authors'. This article summarises the source in our own words; see the original for full details. It is general technical information, not advice on a specific asset.

Related reading

Follow MTIS on LinkedIn for new failure reviews and industry briefings.

Thinning in an overhead line?

Send us the inspection readings and what you know about the operating history. We will tell you what an investigation can establish.