The steel was fine. The quill depth, the wash water rate and the dewpoint margin were not.
A Saudi Aramco team has published a metallurgical investigation of a crude distillation unit (CDU) overhead system in Hydrocarbon Processing (August 2026). Two carbon steel elbows, both seven years old, had thinned in service.
The 48-in. elbow at the top of the column had localised erosion-corrosion where the neutraliser amine stream impinged on the wall. The quill was installed in the elbow itself, inserted to 11% of the pipe diameter against the 30–35% recommended practice, discharged through a slit rather than its angled face, and had no atomising steam.
The 36-in. elbow at the condenser inlet showed general hydrochloric acid (HCl) attack, with up to about 59% wall loss (4.95 mm remaining of 11.8 mm nominal). Deposits contained up to 7.2 wt% chloride and no nitrogen, which ruled out ammonium chloride. Process records showed the dewpoint margin often below the 15°C minimum, and wash water at roughly 1–2.5% against a 4–6% target. The authors name wash water flow as the direct cause.
Metallography showed an ordinary ferrite-pearlite structure. The material was not the problem. The root causes sat in injection design and operating data.
The lesson for any investigation: a metallurgical examination that stops at the sample will confirm the damage mechanism and miss the cause. The process records, injection details and chemical treatment history have to be part of the evidence.
Facing unexplained thinning or a repeat failure? MTIS carries investigations through from the lab to the operating records: https://www.mtis-malaysia.com/failure-investigation.html
Or start structuring the evidence yourself with the MTIS Failure Investigation Assistant: https://www.mtis-malaysia.com/failure-investigator.html
Source: Al-Ghamdi T.A., Aldossary Y.A., Al-Qahtani K.F. and Al-Zahrani E.S., "Metallurgical investigation of crude distillation overhead system: A case study", Hydrocarbon Processing, August 2026. https://www.hydrocarbonprocessing.com/magazine/2026/august/special-focus-plant-safety-and-environment/metallurgical-investigation-of-crude-distillation-overhead-system-a-case-study/